A note on the improved $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method

Recently, Many methods have been proposed for obtaining exact traveling wave solutions of partial differential equations. An example of these methods is the $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method [1] which is used to obtain traveling wave solutions of many models (see for example [2, 3]). Also, many improved and extended versions of this method have been proposed to get more exact solutions of partial differential equations (see for example [4, 5, 6]).

Many papers are published to comment on the classical version of the $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method. For example, the equivalence between the $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method and the tanh method is proved in [7, 8, 9]. Moreover, in [10], it is shown that the $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method is a specific form of the simplest equation method [11].

The improved $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method [5] is used to obtain new exact solutions of some models [12, 13]. In this paper, we show that this improved $(G^{\prime}/G)$- expansion method is equivalent to the tanh method and doesn’t give any new exact solutions of nonlinear partial differential equations.

In this section, we give the detailed description of the tanh method. Suppose that a nonlinear evolution equation (NLEE) with independent variable $u$ and two independent variables $x$ and $t$ is given by

where, $H$ is a polynomial in $u(x,t)$ and its various partial derivatives, in which the highest order derivatives and nonlinear terms are involved. To determine $u$ explicitly, one can follow the following steps:

Step 1: Use the traveling wave transformation:

where, $\nu$ is a constant to be determined latter. Then, the NLEE (1) is reduced to a nonlinear ordinary differential equation (NLODE) for $u=u(\xi)$:

step 2: Suppose that the NLODE (3) has the following solution:

where, $k,b_{i}(i=0,...,n)$ are constants to be determined later, $\xi_{0}$ is an arbitrary constant and $n$ is a positive integer to be determined in step 3.

Step 3: Determine the positive integer $n$ by balancing the highest order derivatives and nonlinear terms in Eq. (3).

Step 4: Substituting Eq. (4) into Eq. (3) and equating expressions of different power of $(\tanh(k(\xi-\xi_{0}))^{i}$ to zero, we obtain coefficients $b_{i}$ and the parameter $k$.

Step 5: Substituting $b_{i}$ and $k$ into Eq. (4), we can obtain the explicit solutions of Eq. (1) immediately.

In this section, we give the detailed description of the improved (G’/G) -expansion method. To determine $u$ in Eq. (1) explicitly using the improved $(G^{\prime}/G)$- expansion method, one can follow the following five steps:

Step 1: Use the traveling wave transformation (2) to reduce the NLEE (1) to the NLODE (3)

Step 2: Suppose that the NLODE (3) has the following solution:

where, $\sigma$ and $a_{i}(i=-n,...,n)$ are constants to be determined later, $n$ is a positive integer, and $G=G(\xi)$ satisfies the following second order linear ordinary differential equation(LODE):

where, $\mu$ is a real constant. The general solutions of Eq. (6) can be listed as follows. When $\mu<0$, we obtain the hyperbolic function solution of Eq. (6)

where, $A_{1}$ and $A_{2}$ are arbitrary constants. When $\mu>0$, we obtain the trigonometric function solution of Eq. (6)

where, $A_{1}$ and $A_{2}$ are arbitrary constants. When $\mu=0$, we obtain the linear solution of Eq. (6)

where, $A_{1}$ and $A_{2}$ are arbitrary constants

Step 3: Determine the positive integer $n$ by balancing the highest order derivatives and nonlinear terms in Eq. (3).

Step 4: Substituting (5) along with (6) into Eq. (6) and then setting all the coefficients of $\left(G^{\prime}/G\right)^{k},(k=1,2,3,...)$of the resulting systems numerator to zero, yields a set of over-determined nonlinear algebraic equations for $\nu,\sigma$ and $a_{i}(i=-n,...,n)$.

Step 5: Assuming that the constants $\nu,\sigma$ and $a_{i}(i=-n,...,n)$ can be obtained by solving the algebraic equations in Step 4, then substituting these constants and the known general solutions of Eq. (6) into (5), we can obtain the explicit solutions of Eq. (1) immediately.

In the second step of the improved $(G^{\prime}/G)$- expansion method let $y=\frac{\left(G^{\prime}/G\right)}{1+\sigma\left(G^{\prime}/G\right)}$, Eqs. (5), (6) are transformed into

The general solution of Eq. (11) is given by [8]

where, $\alpha=\frac{\sigma\mu}{1+\mu\sigma^{2}}$ and $\beta=\frac{\sqrt{-\mu}}{1+\mu\sigma^{2}}$.

Substituting solution (12) into expansion (10) we have

where,

therefore, $u_{2}$ may be rewritten as

hence,

since $\xi_{0}$ is an arbitrary constant, then we can write

where, $\xi_{1}$ is an arbitrary constant. It is now clear that the two methods will give the same solutions expressed in terms of the tanh function.

In this section we will proof that The solution formula (5) will give solutions in the form of the tanh function and the rational function only.

Case 1: When $\mu<0$, we have

So, in this case (when $\mu<0$) Eq. (5) can be rewritten as

where, $\xi_{0}$ is an arbitrary constant.

Case 2: When $\mu>0$, we have

So, in this case (when $\mu>0$) Eq. (5) can be rewritten as

where, $\xi_{0}$ is an arbitrary constant. By considering the formula [14]

Eq. (30) can be reformulated as

which is equivalent to the solution (24) in case 1.

Case 3. When $\mu=0$, in this case we will simply obtain the rational solution.

It is shown that the improved $(G^{\prime}/G)-$ expansion method is equivalent to the tanh method and doesn’t give any new exact solutions of nonlinear partial differential equations.