All bipartite circulants are dispersable
Abstract
We show that a cyclic vertex order due to Yu, Shao and Li gives a dispersable book embedding for any bipartite circulant.
Keywords: edge-coloring, graph drawing, 05C10, 05C15, 05C78.
It has been conjectured [2] that vertex transitive bipartite graphs can be laid out with vertices on the unit circle, with edges as chords, such that there is a Vizing type-1 edge-coloring where no crossings are monochromatic. Such a drawing and coloring is a dispersable book embedding [3].
We proposed this in 1979, omitting vertex transitivity [3], but in 2018, Alam et al [1] found two counterexamples and later Alam et al. [2] showed the existence of an infinite family of regular bipartite graphs, of fixed degree, which require an arbitrarily large number of edge colors to avoid monochrome edge-crossings.
Based on their examples, Alam et al [2] added the qualification of vertex transitivity, and we further conjectured in [12] that vertex transitive non-bipartite graphs have a type-2 edge coloring (i.e., are nearly dispersable). See [9, 11, 14, 16, 15] which support both conjectures.
In [17, Theorem 4.1], Yu, Shao and Li found what we call the YSL-order; see Fig. 1. They used it only for bipartite degree 3 and 4 circulants. In contrast, we show that the following holds and give a short proof.
Theorem 1.
Any bipartite circulant with the YSL-order is dispersable.
The theorem is additional evidence for the conjecture of [2]. Circulants have been one of the more widely used graph-types and so the theorem might have interesting applications. See, e.g., [5, 7, 8, 10].
In fact, the YSL-order also gives dispersable embeddings for the Franklin and Heawood graphs but not for the Desargues graph.
We now briefly sketch some definitions for the reader’s convenience.
A graph is a circulant if , , and there exists such that , where addition is mod . Such a circulant is denoted and the elements in are the jump-lengths. The -distance between two vertices of a circulant is the graph-theoretic distance in ; for instance, the -distance from 2 to 13 is 5.
A graph is dispersable [3] if it has an outerplane drawing (crossings allowed) and an edge-coloring with colors ( maximum degree) such that two edges of the same color neither cross nor share an endpoint. The color-classes (or pages) are matchings for this book embedding.

In a YSL-order, the natural clockwise cyclic order is permuted so that the odd vertices remain, in clockwise order, at the odd positions, while the even vertices are placed at the even-indexed positions but in counterclockwise order. Our argument below shows that it doesn’t matter where 2 is placed. In [17], Yu et al put 2 immediately counterclockwise of 1, so in clockwise direction, their order is
Using characterizations of bipartite circulants by Heuberger [6] and of connected circulants by Boesch and Tindell [4], and the fact that a disjoint union of identical subgraphs is dispersable if the subgraph is dispersable, one sees that to prove Theorem 1, it suffices to show the following.
Theorem 2.
Let , , and let be the largest odd number not exceeding . Then is dispersable under a YSL order, and the edges in each page correspond to a single jump-length.
Proof.
Each page consists of a maximal parallel family of edges which we enumerate in the order they intersect some orthogonal line. We show that (i) the -distance between the endpoints of edge 1 and edge 2 are equal and (ii) the same holds for edge and edge , .
For (i), suppose that and are edges 1 and 2, with occurring consecutively clockwise. Then and , where the signs agree because vertices alternate odd/even and the ordering is opposite for the two parities. Hence, the distance from to is the same as the distance from to . But distance is symmetric.
For (ii), suppose that and are edges and , with
occurring consecutively clockwise but and can be nonconsecutive. Then and , where again both signs must be equal. ∎
For the reader’s convenience, here are the cited theorems.
Theorem 3 (Heuberger [6]).
Let . Then is bipartite if and only if there exists such that , , but does not divide any of the .
For a positive integer, let denote disjoint copies of graph .
Theorem 4 (Boesch & Tindell [4]).
Let be a circulant. Then , .
If is bipartite, then for odd, with as in Theorem 3.
Each maximal family of parallel edges, under the YSL ordering, has constant jump-length which could represent delay, allowing delay to depend on direction. In contrast, for Overbay’s ordering [13, p 82], for a family of parallel edges, jump-lengths vary palindromically and unimodally , with repeated if and only if is even, as one traverses them with respect to a perpendicular line. See Fig. 2.


In applications, the bipartition could be input and output vertices.
References
- [1] J. Md. Alam, M. A. Bekos, M. Gronemann, M. Kaufmann & S. Pupyrev, On dispersable book embeddings, Graph-theoretic Concepts in Computer Science (44th International Workshop, WG 2018, Cottbus, Germany), A. Brandestädt, E. Köhler, & K. Meer, Eds., LNCS 11159 (2018) 1–14, Springer, Cham, Switzerland.
- [2] J. Md. Alam, M. A. Bekos, V. Dujmovič, M. Gronemann, M. Kaufmann & S. Pupyrev, On dispersable book embeddings, Theor. Computer Sci. 861 (2021) 1–22.
- [3] F. R. Bernhart & P. C. Kainen, The book thickness of a graph, J. Comb. Th. B 27 (1979) 320–331.
- [4] F. Boesch & R. Tindell, Circulants and their connectivities, J. Graph Theory 8 (1984) 487–499.
- [5] F. Harary, The maximum connectivity of a graph, Proc. National Acad. of Sci. 48 (1962) 1142–1146.
- [6] C. Heuberger, On planarity and colorability of circulant graphs, Discr. Math. 268 (2003) 153–169.
- [7] X. Huang, A. F. Ramos, & Y. Deng, Optimal circulant graphs as low-latency network topologies, J Supercomput 78(2022) 13491–13510 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11227-022-04396-5
- [8] F.K. Hwang, A survey on multi-loop networks, Theor. Comp. Science 299 (2003) 107–121.
- [9] S. Joslin, P. C. Kainen & S. Overbay, Dispersability of some cycle products, Missouri J. Math. Sci. 33(2) (2021) 206–213
- [10] S. Joslin, S. Overbay & P. C. Kainen, Information as order (?).
- [11] P. C. Kainen. Complexity of products of even cycles, Bull. Inst. Comb. and Its Appl. 62 (2011) 95–102.
- [12] P. C. Kainen, S. Joslin & S. Overbay, On dispersability of some circulants, J Graph Algor. & Appl., to appear.
- [13] S. Overbay, Generalized book embeddings, Ph.D. Dissertation, Fort Collins: Colorado State University, 1998.
- [14] Z. Shao, H. Geng, Z. Li, Matching book thickness of generalized Petersen graphs, Elec. J. Graph Theory and Appl., 10(1) (2022) 173–180.
- [15] Z. Shao, Y. Liu, Z. Li. Matching book embedding of the Cartesian product of a complete graph and a cycle, Ars Combinatoria 153 (2020) 89–97.
- [16] Z. Shao, X. Yu, & Z. Li, On the dispersability of toroidal grids, Appl. Math. & Computation 453 (2023) 128087.
- [17] X. Yu, Z. Shao & Z. Li, On the classification and dispersability of circulant graphs with two jump lengths, arXiv:2310.06612 10 Oct 2023.